Simone de Beauvoir: Psychological Portrait

A CBT Analysis of a Revolutionary Philosopher and Feminist

Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986) embodied one of the most complex intellectual figures of the twentieth century. Author of the feminist manifesto "The Second Sex" (1949), she challenged the certainties of her era by asserting that "one is not born a woman, but becomes one." Her psychological journey reveals deep mechanisms of autonomy, rebellion against established order, and an endless quest for intellectual and existential freedom.

Young's Schemas in Beauvoir

Three early maladaptive schemas structure Simone de Beauvoir's psyche according to Jeffrey Young's approach.

The Emotional Abandonment Schema forms the foundation of her personality. Born into a Parisian bourgeois family, Beauvoir witnessed her family's social collapse following World War I. Her father, once a man of standing, experienced financial ruin. She recounts in "Memoirs of a Dutiful Daughter" (1958) how this instability crystallized her conviction that one can only rely on oneself. This schema explains her fierce independence and her refusal of traditional marriage: she chose Sartre, a free-thinking philosopher rather than a conventional husband, establishing with him a relationship based on mutual autonomy, not emotional fusion. The Injustice/Punishment Schema permeates her entire body of work. Beauvoir perceived social order as fundamentally unjust, particularly toward women. She developed hypersensitivity to inequalities, constant moral outrage at oppression. This nourished her political commitment: she supported revolutionary causes, traveled to Maoist China in 1955, and criticized French colonialism in Algeria. Her "The Ethics of Ambiguity" (1947) theoretically formalized this revolt against injustice perceived as systemic. The Defectiveness/Shame Schema remains more subterranean but operative. A woman in a man's world, a philosopher in an environment dominated by Sartre, she struggled against feelings of inadequacy despite her recognized genius. Her personal journals reveal periods of depression and self-doubt. This schema paradoxically motivated her to overproduce: she wrote novels, essays, and memoirs to prove her worth, to exist beyond the role assigned to women.

Big Five Profile: The Architecture of Her Personality

Openness (9/10): Beauvoir embodied intellectual openness. She explored countercultural ideas, traveled to America and the USSR, adopted existentialist Marxism. Her novel "All Men Are Mortal" (1946) displays overflowing philosophical imagination. Conscientiousness (7/10): Disciplined in her writing, she maintained strict writing routines. However, her political engagement prioritized the cause over personal order: she lived modestly, rejected bourgeois conventions. Extraversion (6/10): Sociable in intellectual circles, she frequented Café de Flore assiduously, led debates, but remained reserved in broader social contexts. She preferred intellectual exchange to superficial socializing. Agreeableness (4/10): Critical, even confrontational dimension. She did not seek reconciliation. Her critiques of traditional marriage, imposed motherhood, and female domesticity upset her contemporaries. She preferred uncomfortable truth to harmony. Neuroticism (7/10): Beauvoir suffered from chronic existential anxiety. Her personal journals reveal depressive phases, anguish facing the absurd. She used tobacco and, according to some biographers, amphetamines to manage this inner tension. This emotional vulnerability fueled her existential quest and her empathetic understanding of human suffering.

Attachment Style: Anxious-Avoidant Attachment

Beauvoir displayed a complex attachment profile, oscillating between anxiety and emotional distance. Her love for Sartre (whom she met in 1929) revealed relational anxiety: she feared abandonment, demanded complete transparency, intellectual communion. Simultaneously, she refused fusion: she insisted on autonomy, refused marriage, maintained her own romantic relationships.

Her relationships with her lovers (notably with Olga Kosakiewicz and Bianca Lamblin) testified to attachment tinged with ambivalence: intense desire for intimacy coupled with a need for control and independence. This style generated relational tension that she would sublimate in her novels, notably "She Came to Stay" (1943) where jealousy and emotional possession become central.

Preferred Defense Mechanisms

Intellectualization: Beauvoir transformed every personal conflict into a philosophical question. Her unhappiness became material for existential reflection. She theorized her experience as a woman, as mortal, as a situated being to extract universal significance from it. Sublimation: Relational energy and emotional conflicts were channeled into literary and philosophical creation. Love too complex with Sartre became the dynamic of "The Second Sex". Rationalization: She justified her radical life choices (absence of children, multiple relationships, refusal of marriage) through coherent philosophical argumentation, minimizing personal doubts and guilt. Denial: She long minimized Sartre's domination in their intellectual partnership, asserted theoretical equality while the outside world perceived her first as "Sartre's companion".

CBT Perspectives and Cognitive Reformulation

Identifying automatic thoughts: Beauvoir operated with polarized thoughts: "I must prove my worth through intellectual productivity" or "Political engagement is an absolute moral obligation". These thoughts, while generating her genius, created performance anxiety. Working on adapted schemas: Rather than eliminating her schemas, Beauvoir sublimated them. Her injustice schema transformed into ethical vigilance. Her abandonment schema became creative independence. CBT could have helped her soften this vigilance, accept normal human dependence without guilt. Emotional restructuring: Faced with chronic depression, CBT would have proposed behavioral techniques: behavioral activation, gradual reduction of caffeine and tobacco, restructuring catastrophic thoughts about death (an obsessive theme for her).

Conclusion: The Universal Lesson

Simone de Beauvoir teaches us that maladaptive schemas can become creative forces. Her existential anxiety did not paralyze her but mobilized her. However, she also reminds us of the psychological cost: depression, tumultuous relationships, substance dependence.

The CBT perspective invites us toward an intermediate wisdom: recognize our defense mechanisms while accepting them, transform our wounds into consciousness rather than ideological weapons, and cultivate authentic interdependence. Beauvoir said "freedom is being responsible." We would add: true freedom is also accepting our human vulnerability and making it a relational force, not merely an existential one.

---

Also Worth Reading

• Napoleon Bonaparte Psychological Portrait Personality
• Voltaire Psychological Portrait

Recommended Reading:

• Reinvent Your Life — Jeffrey Young